Welcome to Pixpet!  Login or  Register Account   Resend Activation Email  Forgot Password? Dark Mode
Posts Overview
Describe the Best Cookie (19 Posts and 87 Views)
Topic Tags: food, cookie, dessert, chocolate chip
Member
Forum Moderator

Jan 30th, 2019
Posts: 723
Pixpets: 336
Pixdex: 139
4 Years ago
May 4th, 2019 - 9:35 PM
Nr. 1 #18829
everyone has an opinion on what the best cookie looks/tastes like! mine is an underbaked chocolate chunk cookie with crispy edges. this is my favourite recipe. extra chocolate and nuts, and it should have plenty of salt for that salty-sweet dough.

(white chocolate, macadamia nut, and cranberry cookies are a close second place, but chocolate chip just out of the oven can't be beat)
Kookaburra's Signature
Member

Mar 26th, 2019
Posts: 80
Pixpets: 49
Pixdex: 55
4 Years ago
May 4th, 2019 - 11:04 PM
Nr. 2 #18837
It's honestly hard to pick a favorite, and I'd argue that it depends on my mood.

I recently made some pillowy matcha cookies from scratch that were *divine,* though. And the bakery I worked at had a brown butter salted caramel cookie that was to die for.

But I also like my crunchy, overbaked chocolate chip cookies if I'm not feeling the fancier ones. :)

Edit:
Pictured: Matcha Cookies

They looked kinda ugly but came out great for a first try on the recipe.
Member
Early Adopter
Forum Super Moderator

Apr 6th, 2018
Posts: 1560
Pixpets: 334
Pixdex: 156
4 Years ago
May 5th, 2019 - 12:00 AM
Nr. 3 #18842
@/Kookaburra
I'm already liking this thread... xD That recipe looks amazing. And since it was adapted from an Alton Brown recipe, you know it's probably perfectly engineered, lol

@/Klaora
Matcha cookies sound really interesting! I wish our local bakery sold stuff like that. Someday I'll have to make a small batch just to try them.

As for me I do have a lot of respect for homemade cookies, but I'm one of those slobs who'd rather eat a crunchy, processed, name-brand cookie like Chips Ahoy, Famous Amos, or Oreo. There's just something about them that's so good... -แด—-
BK47's Signature
Helpful Links

       

avatar art by PauMol   |   custom bars by Wayvern
Member

Sep 20th, 2018
Posts: 85
Pixpets: 43
Pixdex: 51
4 Years ago
May 5th, 2019 - 12:49 AM
Nr. 4 #18851
Oh.....tough choice. Snicker doodles? Oatmeal raisin? One of those 2, although I MUCH prefer the latter.
dragontamer1990's Signature
Member

Mar 26th, 2019
Posts: 80
Pixpets: 49
Pixdex: 55
4 Years ago
May 5th, 2019 - 2:01 AM
Nr. 5 #18860 1
@BK47
If it's an actual bakery and not a supermarket bakery, you can sometimes request special orders, especially if it's for an event of some kind. At least that's how ours was. c: We didn't usually have less popular flavors in stock, but we could make them. ^^
Though I have a soft spot for those store bought cookies, too! The sheer price and convenience can't be beat. (Also, I love my Oreos soggy from milk where it just falls apart. :P )
Member

May 15th, 2019
Posts: 56
Pixpets: 24
Pixdex: 29
4 Years ago
Jun 10th, 2019 - 9:45 PM
Nr. 6 #21732
I haven't baked this kind of cookies myself, but I really like dark (as in, the dough is chocolate-colored) chocolate chip cookies that have even more chocolate inside.
Lemonski's Signature
Member

Jul 22nd, 2019
Posts: 9
Pixpets: 1
Pixdex: 0
4 Years ago
Jul 22nd, 2019 - 4:11 AM
Nr. 7 #24692
for me it's chocolate chip that's on the softer side or white chocolate macadamia nut.
Member

Jul 9th, 2019
Posts: 9
Pixpets: 105
Pixdex: 26
4 Years ago
Jul 23rd, 2019 - 6:30 PM
Nr. 8 #24834
Slightly crisp on the outside, chewy gooey goodness inside.
Member

Jan 5th, 2019
Posts: 143
Pixpets: 208
Pixdex: 50
4 Years ago
Jul 23rd, 2019 - 6:43 PM
Nr. 9 #24836
probably chocolate chip is the most ideal. i hate crunchy cookies, they've gotta be soft and preferably warm. the best is when you bake them yourself and have a cold glass of milk to go with it. i think dipping cookies just makes them soggy, and i think the best experience is just taking a swig of milk between bites to clear your palate a bit. same can be said for most pastries, really.
lumiet's Signature
Member

Jun 1st, 2019
Posts: 280
Pixpets: 20
Pixdex: 35
4 Years ago
Jul 24th, 2019 - 4:38 AM
Nr. 10 #24865
Chewy Jamaican oatmeal cookies with fruit inside, I like all cookies though
Ricohard's Signature
ALL HAIL RICOHARD!
Member

Aug 17th, 2019
Posts: 26
Pixpets: 26
Pixdex: 21
4 Years ago
Aug 18th, 2019 - 4:19 AM
Nr. 11 #26835
A chocolate chip cookie just warm enough to where the cookie just falls off and the chocolate melts in your mouth instantly!
Nicosetsu's Signature
Icon made by SamiDoesArts!
Member

Jun 1st, 2019
Posts: 280
Pixpets: 20
Pixdex: 35
4 Years ago
Aug 18th, 2019 - 4:29 AM
Nr. 12 #26839
Strawberry cheesecake in the form of a crispy cookie with ooey gooey insides and a scent of raw vanilla
Ricohard's Signature
ALL HAIL RICOHARD!
Member

Aug 20th, 2019
Posts: 6
Pixpets: 6
Pixdex: 2
4 Years ago
Aug 21st, 2019 - 12:50 AM
Nr. 13 #27116
Personally, I don't really eat cookies as I can no longer have any kind of chocolate, but when I was around 4-5 years old(?) I loved white chocolate chip cookies and would eat as many as I could.

These days, if I want a cookie I get the one least amount of chocolate on it and then pick all the chocolate off it until I'm just left with the dough :D.
Kasperian's Signature
Member

Aug 17th, 2019
Posts: 7
Pixpets: 8
Pixdex: 8
4 Years ago
Aug 21st, 2019 - 1:22 AM
Nr. 14 #27118
Snickerdoodles. Need I say more.
Member

Jul 7th, 2019
Posts: 2
Pixpets: 43
Pixdex: 40
4 Years ago
Aug 21st, 2019 - 2:45 AM
Nr. 15 #27120
my grandma makes really soft chocolate-chip cookies that i love! they're irregularly shaped and as i said before, super soft and kind of on the thin side but god i love them so much :'3 i'm craving cookies now
Member

Aug 31st, 2019
Posts: 6
Pixpets: 60
Pixdex: 63
4 Years ago
Sep 6th, 2019 - 7:20 PM
Nr. 16 #28285
I have a hard time picking a favorite for just about anything, but I really love double chocolate, peanut butter with chocolate chips, and snickerdoodles.
Member

Jul 12th, 2019
Posts: 23
Pixpets: 39
Pixdex: 45
4 Years ago
Sep 13th, 2019 - 5:01 PM
Nr. 17 #28681
I... have a weakness for caramel. Throw some Score bits into any cookie and I'll call it perfect!
Member

Sep 17th, 2019
Posts: 24
Pixpets: 7
Pixdex: 4
4 Years ago
Sep 17th, 2019 - 2:23 PM
Nr. 18 #28882
My favorite cookies are chocolate tops! I like to eat all the breading off the bottom and then eat the chocolate that’s left!
RebellingSocks's Signature
Member

Apr 3rd, 2019
Posts: 73
Pixpets: 97
Pixdex: 107
4 Years ago
Sep 17th, 2019 - 4:35 PM
Nr. 19 #28890
I cant even think up of a favorite cookie because i like so many, although chocolate chip and gingerbread cookies are some of my favorites!
Register
Not Registered Yet?
Join for free
Recent Activity
Pixpet Sponsor Support
Our Previous/Current Super Sponsors
Sponsor
Get your own Sponsor Banner on Pixpet (Rules) + 100 Pixpet Ticket Coupons/Month for Item Commissions!

Super Sponsor
Get your own Sponsor Banner on Pixpet (Rules) + Your Own Pixpet after 6 months support (not consecutive) on this tier! (Rules)
Totodile2064 Super Sponsor for 41 Months
bgyoshi Super Sponsor for 33 Months
Chicken_Raptor Super Sponsor for 16 Months
Dusk Super Sponsor for 15 Months
Tybaxel Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Sherrice Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Ignis Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Takkju Super Sponsor for 5 Months
Phoenix Super Sponsor for 4 Months
Kookaburra Super Sponsor for 2 Months
Isegard Super Sponsor for 1 Month
Become Pixpet Sponsor
Pixpet Chat
(slowly rebranding)  [jak]dacrowe  Amu  AnimusReach (GreySkyMorning)  b...  BeasRabbit  Brisingr12  c...  c...  c...  Cactuskate  Carpo (ign: CarpoPyronite )  Charzea  ckolb  DarkStarDragon  DarylSun  Dynosaur  ECDMDragon  Emrys  Fandomzzz1234  Fandramon  Goatly  Hikari  horse (CyberneticCaballus)  hunter-z  Iségard  Jinxie  Jyxxie  Kino_Kari  Klaora  Komodo  KyoVyrkai  Latimer  LAV  Leonidas (DraconisLeonidas)  lophius (monkfishlover)  LuciDatum  maggicked  Melia  Mew  Mew304  Moonlightelf  NACHOLINE  Nicol (Uri)  PearlyGirl  Pinkapop  Psicose  PuppyToast  Queen of Nightmares  Queenie  Rachel the Raichu  Rackiera  Rainbow is an artist  RainbowFox68  Reetno  Rexsaurus  Silver  skykitten (bunny), ace attorney  Skylark Starflower  Smidgey  Snake  Snær  Starfire Dragon  Steveni  Tangaroa  theBurnt  Tiffanbrill  TwistedGate  Val  w...  WolfDragonPlasma  Zen00  Zetta  โ˜พ lynn  ๐ŸŒˆ^^Niji_Crab^^๐Ÿ’ซ  ๐ŸŒน EVA  ๐Ÿ”ณ๐Ÿ”ฒ 
Log in to join!
Social Media
Also subscribe to our other social media accounts if you want to stay informed!

1 User Online (Last 15 Minutes)
Windand 0 hidden users

Welcome our newest user: BettaGalaxy94
Most Users Online: 126 on Mar 19th, 2019 - 7:07 PM

Forum Stats: Total 45268 Posts in 2827 Topics.

Early Adopter Patreon Supporter Sponsor Super Sponsor Site Artist Discord Moderator Forum Moderator Forum Super Moderator Game Moderator Game Super Moderator Administrator