Welcome to Pixpet!  Login or  Register Account   Resend Activation Email  Forgot Password? Dark Mode
Single Post Permalink
Member
Early Adopter
Forum Super Moderator

Apr 6th, 2018
Posts: 1565
Pixpets: 322
Pixdex: 157
4 Years ago
Nov 17th, 2019 - 5:56 AM
Nr. 1 #32098 2
A few days ago, I was reading the thread "why does the auction system exist?", and there are quite a lot of passionate voices in that thread. As staff, we understand that the reason players raise concerns is because they care about the game and want to see it succeed, not because they're out to cause drama. However, also as staff, it can sometimes be hard to determine whether players are misunderstanding a game mechanic, criticizing something based on personal preference, or raising a valid concern. After all, we can't see from each other's gameplay perspectives. One thing that's clear, though, is that disillusionment with the auction system has become common, and we want players to know that they're being heard. So I've compiled this list as a way to make it easier for Komodo to see the community's suggestions about the auction system. That way, he can decide for himself if the auction system should be improved.

Please keep in mind that Komodo is currently working on Pixpet Adventure, so if/when he considers whether or not to improve auctions, it will most likely be after that's released and has undergone significant debugging. Additionally, we don't know how Pixpet Adventure will affect other aspects of the site once it's released, so some of these suggestions may become unneeded or require modifying.

These suggestions are open to discussion, and I'm more than willing to edit them or add more suggestions. Please remember to be constructive.

Community Suggestions

  • Implemented! Minimum bid increase. Several players have expressed irritation towards the +1 bid increase, both as buyers and sellers. Sellers are often inundated with auction notifications, only to find that each bid was +1 and they could've made more PC on the item through other means. Buyers take advantage of the +1 bid increase and snipeguard to win by unfair attrition, rather than by bidding reasonable amounts. Allowing sellers to set a minimum bid increase would force fair bidding and reduce snipeguard abuse. If this is implemented, ideally the minimum bid increase set by the seller would be clearly displayed on each auction.


  • Custom snipeguard. Fairly self-explanatory. Some players don't like the length of the current snipeguard, mostly because of what was explained in the previous suggestion. If this is implemented, ideally the snipeguard length set by the seller would be clearly displayed on each auction.


  • Alternate snipeguard suggestion: snipeguard automatically shortens after triggered a certain number of times. (From Rizlak's post) After snipeguard is triggered a certain number of times, reduce it to 5 minutes or something (make it very clear on the page that this will occur, "in X more bids, snipeguard will be reduced to Y minutes").


  • Minimum bid automatically increases by X% after the snipeguard is triggered. (From Rizlak's post) People intent on getting the best deal will have to actively engage in the bidding, and there's less reason to wait if you're willing to bid higher.


  • Auto-bidding/set max bid. This would be an option for buyers who are asleep while an auction happens, or simply don't have the time to babysit an auction. Being able to set your max bid, and letting the game auto-bid for you based on the minimum bid increase for that auction, would at least allow players to have a chance at winning an auction even if they can't be present for it.


  • Anonymous bidding + winner not shown (except to the winner). As we've seen, not everyone is able to view the competitive nature of auctions as something they shouldn't take personally, let alone consider enjoyable. But if you don't know who's bidding against you, this reduces the resentment towards other players that can arise with auctions. While it's true that you could probably still find out who's bidding against you via Discord because people often discuss what they're bidding on, it would still be beneficial to have this feature. Not everyone uses Discord or the forums, and at the very least it would help to devenomize a game mechanic that breeds animosity among some in the community.


  • Implemented! Instant buy option, or usershop search function. Much of the frustration with auctions stems from the simple fact that you have to wait for them, and with players' busy lives and varying time zones, not everyone can babysit auctions. By adding an instant buy option for auctions, or a search function for usershops, this would relieve a lot of stress for players. Also, pretty much every petsite has some form of instant buy with a search function, and they haven't burned to the ground. The major downside of this is that auctions would be used less. Of course, then we'd have to go into the debate of "Why would that be a bad thing?"

    Some good suggestions offered by Klaora to retain the appeal of auctions if a usershop search function is implemented:

              1. Limit usershop items by rarity and type.
              2. Tax the usershop.
              3. Increase auction slots.


  • Shorter auction times. Similar reason as instant buy option.


  • Implemented! When placing items or eggs on the market/usershop, the price parameter should have the sellback price entered by default, instead of 0. This would help inform players who unknowingly price items and eggs for less than the sellback price.


Staff/My Suggestions

  • Increase the auction tax to 10% to curb the current PC inflation. Or add another type of PC sink, such as a server marketplace, similar to the basic ingredients shop. This is the type of suggestion that may be affected by Pixpet Adventure when it's released, but we're not sure how much.


  • Filter auctions by ending during custom time parameters. This is for the people who miss the end of an auction because of their time zone (so, everybody). Being able to filter auctions by specific end time ranges might help with some of that. Of course, in some situations it could also just filter out the only auction that's selling what you need, but it may still be useful to have this.


  • Increase auction slots significantly (15 - 30).
BK47's Signature
Helpful Links

       

avatar art by PauMol   |   custom bars by Wayvern
Last edited by BK47, Mar 12th, 2020 - 1:21 AM
Register
Not Registered Yet?
Join for free
Recent Activity
Pixpet Sponsor Support
Our Previous/Current Super Sponsors
Sponsor
Get your own Sponsor Banner on Pixpet (Rules) + 100 Pixpet Ticket Coupons/Month for Item Commissions!

Super Sponsor
Get your own Sponsor Banner on Pixpet (Rules) + Your Own Pixpet after 6 months support (not consecutive) on this tier! (Rules)
Totodile2064 Super Sponsor for 41 Months
bgyoshi Super Sponsor for 33 Months
Chicken_Raptor Super Sponsor for 16 Months
Dusk Super Sponsor for 15 Months
Tybaxel Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Sherrice Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Ignis Super Sponsor for 6 Months
Takkju Super Sponsor for 5 Months
Phoenix Super Sponsor for 4 Months
Kookaburra Super Sponsor for 2 Months
Isegard Super Sponsor for 1 Month
Become Pixpet Sponsor
Pixpet Chat
(slowly rebranding)  a...  aly  Amu  AnimusReach (GreySkyMorning)  b...  b...  Beebs (Bee)  Brandon  Brettney ๐Ÿˆ  Brisingr12  c...  c...  Calixita ๐Ÿ’•๐ŸŒบ๐ŸŒˆ  Captain Owlin  Celes โœจ(goldencelestine)  cisee  citrine  ckolb  CorgisaurusRex  DarkStarDragon  DarylSun  DCSA [M.Cat]  dokideku  DrowsyPanda  Dynosaur  Electric Prince  Ellix  FairyForestKing  Fandomzzz1234  Fandramon  Fren Derg  ghost™ | rythec  Hikari  Imp Press  issa Pando! [PandosHere]  ivnthglxygd  Ixen  Jinxie  Jyxxie  k...  Kino_Kari  LAV  Leonidas (DraconisLeonidas)  Li0nless  lorang  luna (ign Aigis)  maggicked  MagicSpyglass  MasterDaye  MayuriTheTyrogue  Melia  Mew  Moonlightelf  Nat  nomadic dragon  Ozanthium  Parthuin  PearlyGirl  Pikalil  primerose  Psicose  PuppyToast  Pyromander  Queen of Nightmares  Queenie  Rackiera  Rainbow is an artist  RainbowFox68  Ravenstag  redfailhawk  Rexsaurus  Samsci  Silly  Silver  skykitten (bunny), ace attorney  Skylark Starflower  Snake  Soulmates4Ever  Starfire Dragon  Steveni  Syria Sirlay  Tangaroa  tetra  theBurnt  Will + Adam  WolfDragonPlasma  Zen00  Zetta  Zombie PigeonPun  ๐ŸŒˆ^^Niji_Crab^^๐Ÿ’ซ  ๐Ÿ’šTangledPsycho17๐Ÿ’š  ๐Ÿ”ณ๐Ÿ”ฒ 
Log in to join!
Social Media
Also subscribe to our other social media accounts if you want to stay informed!

9 Users Online (Last 15 Minutes)

Welcome our newest user: noxicity
Most Users Online: 126 on Mar 19th, 2019 - 7:07 PM

Forum Stats: Total 45305 Posts in 2832 Topics.

Early Adopter Patreon Supporter Sponsor Super Sponsor Site Artist Discord Moderator Forum Moderator Forum Super Moderator Game Moderator Game Super Moderator Administrator